Let’s Talk About The Judas Contract.

Hey guys, Naru here, and like many of you, I just finished watching the newly released trailer for the next DC Uiverse animated movie, The Judas Contract. As you may remember, when I talked about Teen Titans last year, I had a lot to say about The Judas Contract and the way the original series handled the Terra storyline, and while I don’t take any of it back, I do feel that there was a lot that I left unsaid, both in regards to the series, the storyline, and even about Teen Titans Go, weirdly enough. As it happens, I also had a spot for the month of february that was still vacant, and while I was thinking about filling it with something from my stockpile of material, the trailer for Judas gave me a much better idea… Instead, I should take advantage of this opportunity by going into my further thoughts on these subjects. This won’t be a structured review, and I really have no plan in mind for any of it, so let’s get crackin’ and see what happens.

I was fairly young when Teen Titans came out, and I had little to no history of reading comic books, so at the time, I had no idea Terra was anything but an original character made up for the cartoon. I liked her design, and thought she was kind of cute in the “Pretty blonde girl with a troubled family life” kind of way, you know, the kind of character one of the Fanning girls would be typecast as. I thought her powers were kind of cool, and I liked the idea that they were adding a new character to the series, but even then, the teenage Naru cringed over how lame and badly written the episode was. That’s not to say it was unsalvageable, and it certainly held enough iconic status to keep it interesting, but if Betrayal hadn’t made my Top Ten Worst episodes list, this one would have slid into the number 10 slot, if for no other reason than the opening segment alone, where Terra encounters the titans after kiting a giant scorpion, and Slade just randomly appears on the scene to speak to literally nobody.

I didn’t initially hate Terra. Even now, she’s never really inspired that much ire from me. I just really hated, both then and moreso now, how hipster her character was. She was written to be the early 2000’s cool girl, the mysterious chick who blows in out of nowhere, crashes on your coach, enjoys your company but never makes any long term connections, and then just leaves. I remember even then thinking “How the hell does she keep herself fed?” And while you could theorize that she sleeps around for sustenance, that would make more sense in the comic than in the cartoon. She’s with the titans too briefly to really build a relationship that makes their offer to bring her in as a team member believable, as she wasn’t the first hero friend they’d made, and the offer never really came up before. Also, how come they had a training course that seemed specifically designed for her powers? I know it wasn’t, but if they brought Aqualad in, and his first challenge was a water course, I’d like to see him try a few more challenges first.

And we all know what happens from there… Slade knows Terra in some way that’s never really explained, Slade’s defeated, and some silly misunderstanding sends her straight into his arms. I really don’t get that. If you’ve got the choice between fighting for good and fighting for evil, I could see the appeal of either side, but your choice of sides should have more influencing it than just “He talked about me behind my back!” Yeah, I got approached by The Jedi, and they seemed really cool, but one of them made a snide comment, so Execute Order 66 on their asses! Kill them all, except ironically for the one who made the comment, I’ll spare that dude, he seemed on the level! And then she runs away, not noticing that Slade’s got some kind of camera flying right alongside her. I mean, how else does his monitor have her at that angle? Whatever. It’s not the worst episode, but combine all of those issues with the show’s weird pseudo-anime sight gags, and it came pretty close to being one of them.

This would be followed by Titan Rising and Betrayal, which I’ve talked about at length, as they were respectively among my favorite and least favorite episodes. After them, we’d get the finale, where Slade and Terra’s plans went into motion, and aside from a few hiccups here and there, I thought those episodes were okay. They had a lot of ground to make up for after that piece of shit Betrayal episode, but I think they did a fine job of it. I don’t remember being too sad when Terra got frozen, although I could be wrong since it’s been over ten years since I first saw the episode, but considering they couldn’t kill anybody in a kids show, it wasn’t the worst way to take her out. Having said that, my lack of an emotional connection to Terra wasn’t the only reason that the final episode Things Change didn’t really bother me. Actually, if there was ever an episode that I wish I’d talked about at some point in my last two Teen Titans posts, it’s that one. I still don’t really love or hate the episode, but it feels like kind of an important one, or at least too important to be left undiscussed.

People get so passionate on both sides about this episode, with some claiming that it cheapens one of the most emotionally intense moment of the series for no good reason(a complaint that I would argue holds more truth with Red Star), and others claiming that logic aside, it’s the right kind of respectfully nostalgic note to hit for a beloved show that was about to end. I personally hated how Terra’s status was never confirmed or explained, and that bringing her back without making any effort to explain how was just plain lazy. That is, I DID think that, up until I read a fan theory on the episode. It stated that, much like the series itself, Terra was brought back in an incomplete way thanks to the Trigon saga. The theory goes on to state that when Trigon’s power turned the people of the world to stone, and Raven’s power turned everyone back, she may have unknowingly did so to Terra, to. Terra, like the rest of the world, was revived from stone, the difference being that she’d been petrified for so long that she’d lost her memories as a result. Actually kind of makes sense, doesn’t it?

And yet, if I’m being completely honest with you guys… With 100 percent brutal sincerity, no filters, no consideration for anyone else’s feelings… I liked Terra better in Teen Titans Go. Now, that’s not an endorsement of Go… I’d never try to tell you to watch that cesspool of shit… No, you know what? This has to be said. Teen Titans Go was a good idea. Conceptually, there was nothing wrong with it. The original cartoon was great, and it can never be replicated or undone, but if you’re going to reboot it for modern times, it could never have happened in the 2010s. I’m not sure it would have been allowed to exist in today’s market, the way Cartoon Network’s going. On the other hand, a chibi style comedy show with the original voice actors reprising their roles was a great idea. The execution was bad, because the people writing it clearly don’t give a shit and can’t take criticism, and throw out the most insulting excuses to avoid putting forth any effort, but it could have been awesome. It didn’t have to suck.

There have been several Teen Titans Go segments that I liked, although I’m mostly referring to self-contained bite-size Youtube clips, and not to entire episodes. But if there have been any episodes that I was able to enjoy from start to finish, it was the Terra episodes. Well, okay, the double dating one wasn’t very good, but I’d still rather watch that over Betrayal. I’ve said before that while a Judas contract adaptation doesn’t have to be faithful, your best bet is to either write her as 100 percent hero or 100 percent villain. You can TRY to write a deep and complex arc for her character, but look at how the original cartoon fucked THAT up. I loved Titan Rising for just pretending to write her as a straight up hero, and to take things one step farther, Teen Titans Go writes her as a full villain, going all the way in with it. And here’s the best part; Since the Toddler Titans are fucking idiots, she doesn’t even have to be that threatening about it! Her character was consistent, her motives were clear, and she just over-all made sense. The connections to Slade were removed from her, but considering the tone she struck in this rendition, that’s probably for the best. She was just a mercenary who wanted to sell the Titans secrets, then she wanted revenge on them for banishing her to the dimension where they threw away their garbage. It was funny, and it worked.

So where does that leave the upcoming movie? Well, the Justice League vs. Teen Titans movie was awesome, so I have high hopes. That movie did what Batman vs. Superman failed to do… It managed to tie in a Justice League side story with one of the most intimidating and high profile villains of the main characters’ lineup, and it all gelled together with mixed to positive results. But then again, they also did The Killing joke, so it’s fair to say that Filler is not their forte. And with the lineup that the first Teen Titans movie from the DC animated Universe has set us up with, there’s gonna have to be some filler in this puppy. Now of course, that might not be the case… The Judas Contract was quite a bit longer than the Killing Joke comic, and as long as they go into Deathstroke’s backstory, they really shouldn’t be hurting for content. And more good news, it looks like he’s in it! Part of the job’s already done! But it’s the lack of Wondergirl, Kid Flash and the original robin that I find disconcerting.

See, here’s the most important thing about The Judas Contract… Timing. It happened at the perfect time. When Terra was introduced to the team, Kid flash was on his way out, Robin was transitioning to Nightwing, and Wondergirl was engaged to be married. It was a time of great change, and a major turning point for the status quo, which made her intro feel all the more natural. It’s at times like that when you WANT new characters to enter the story and fill in for the old ones. That’s why her betrayal felt like such an intense slap in the face to both readers and the cast alike. That’s not to say their removal from the story would hurt it’s over-all flow, or cut off any serious amount of screen time, but it will probably take some of the impact off of Terra’s turn. then again, since everyone who knows anything about the Titans KNOWS how treacherous she is, I doubt her betrayal is going to be a surprise for any fans anyway. Of course, it’s hard to tell what they’re going to do with her, because she’s barely in the trailer.

From what I can tell, it looks like they aged her up a bit, which could mean that they’re going ahead with making her Deathstroke’s lover girl, and they want to avoid all the ephebophilic ickines, and I’m okay with that. They might cover for the element of change that set up Terra’s character arc by having the otherwise inexplicably older Starfire and Cyborg try to move on from the team. The only Hang-up I’m having is that it feels too early. Say what you will about the new team, but we haven’t had enough time with them for Terra’s threat to really mean something to us. But then again, they pulled off Trigon, so I guess we’ll see how it goes. Either way, it’s going to be different, and different doesn’t necessarily mean bad. It’s a matter of execution, not accuracy. I liked what they did with the last movie, and for the love of God, I even liked what Teen Titans Go did with her character. If you can’t make an adaptation the same, for whatever reason, you shouldn’t force it, and you should find a new way to present the material that will work. And while they’re at it, they should make an adaptation of Hush already! I’ve waited too damn long for it!

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Manga Toritsukareru Koto

"We are not obsessed. We just need anime and manga in our life."

Anime Girls NYC

Anime all day everyday!

100WordAnime

Reviewing anime in 100 words (approximately)

The Fullmetal Narcissist

Your home for in-depth anime reviews!

Otaku Nate's lost worlds of Anime

Taking you to Realms unknown in the anime spectrum!

Jennifer Paetsch

I write and draw and sometimes people like it! Wow!

Fujinsei

Embrace Your Inner Otaku

The Houston Aspie Blogging Collective

We're aspies and we know it.

LMG comic updates

Find the webcomic at lmgcomic.com

nolazyway

Anime, Manga and Reviews

watchmemakestuffs

My site about cosplay

Lily Art

Where Imagination Runs Free

Classic Anime Blog

This WordPress.com site is the cat’s pajamas

The Daily Post

The Art and Craft of Blogging

The WordPress.com Blog

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

%d bloggers like this: